|
Value Vault: Archived Analysis
NOTE: This page has been archived and the commentary, data, and links on this page are current as of the last date indicated.
|
Dundee Bancorp Inc. (TSX:DBC.A)
|
|
 |
|
|
 |
 |
|
|
| ABOUT THE COMPANY |
|
Dundee Bancorp Inc. is a merchant banking and financial services holding
company that was founded in 1991. Dundee Bancorp manages its own investment
portfolio and provides wealth management to financial advisors, institutional
investors, corporations and individuals through its 85% interest in Dundee
Wealth Management (DWM). DWM has over $6 billion of assets under management and
operations include the Dynamic Mutual Funds, Dundee Securities, Dundee Private
Investors and the Dundee Insurance Agency.
|
|
 |
|
|
| FINANCIAL DATA |
| |
1998 |
1999 |
2000e |
| Earnings per Share ($) |
0.51 |
0.46 |
0.60 |
| Price to Earnings (times) |
31.4 |
34.8 |
26.7 |
| Dividend ($) |
0 |
0 |
0 |
| Dividend Yield (%) |
0 |
0 |
0 |
| Book Value ($) |
18.00 |
19.40 |
20.50 |
| Price to Book Value (times) |
0.89 |
0.82 |
0.78 |
|
|
|
| PRICE GRAPH |
 |
|
 |
|
|
| WHY ABC FUNDS BOUGHT THIS COMPANY |
|
Ned Goodman, Dundee's Chairman, President and CEO, originally purchased the
Dynamic Funds from Beutel Goodman and built the organization into what it is
today. The company has expanded to provide investment banking services,
securities brokerage, capital management, investment advisory services and a
line of mutual fund products. Dundee also manages its own investment portfolio
and has significant interests in such companies as Zemex Corporation, Micro
Tempus, Dimethaid Research, Black Hawk Mining and Breakwater Resources.
Currently, the share price is significantly below its all-time high of $43 and
trades at a discount to its $30 net asset value. The disappointing share price
performance presented a buying opportunity and we believe that Dundee Bancorp
offers excellent value for the patient investor.
In fiscal 1999, Dundee Bancorp reported consolidated earnings per share of
$0.46, compared to $0.51 in 1998. The Dynamic Funds experienced net redemptions
for the year, which hindered the growth of Dundee's earnings. Book value
increased from $18.00 in 1998 to $19.40 in 1999, despite the decline in mutual
fund assets. In 1999 Dundee acquired Fortune Financial and Peelbrooke Capital to
increase its financial offerings and improve its tax effectiveness. Investor
dissatisfaction, however, caused Dundee's share price to bottom at a 52-week low
of $12.60 in November 1999 after attaining a high of $17.40 in July. Management
is obviously concerned with the lack of share price performance and is buying
back stock because it is cheap and also to demonstrate its commitment to
long-term growth.
We believe that Dundee Bancorp is extraordinarily attractive as a pure net
asset value play. However, Dundee Bancorp has a relatively complex corporate
structure with several subsidiaries and therefore suffers from a severe holding
company discount. Recently, attempts were made to simplify the ownership
structure but consumers were still confused with the branding of the Dynamic,
Infinity and Power mutual funds. This problem is being corrected and Dundee now
operates its mutual fund segment under the Dynamic banner. As previously
mentioned, the company experienced net redemptions in fiscal 1999 as its value
investment philosophy fell out-of-favour. Dundee responded by expanding its
product line and added both growth and focus investment strategies. These new
management styles and significantly improved investment performance should
strengthen sales in 2000.
Although out of favour, Dundee Bancorp is an attractive value investment. We
expect that as mutual fund sales pick up and investor confidence returns,
Dundee's share price will improve. If the inherent value of the company
continues to go unrecognized, it is not unreasonable to suggest that Dundee
Wealth Management, the publicly traded and 85% owned subsidiary, could be sold
outright to another financial institution. This event would monetize
considerable value to Dundee Bancorp and could be a significant catalyst to a
higher share price. In any case, ABC Funds' purchase of Dundee Bancorp was an
opportunity to buy into a value-oriented financial services company at a
fundamentally attractive price.
ABC Funds
June 2000
|
|
 |
|
|
| UPDATES |
| September 29, 2000
Dundee Bancorp reported its financial results for the first half of
fiscal 2000. Substantial revenue and asset growth reflects the
acquisition of Fortune Financial by Dundee Bancorp's subsidiary, Dundee
Wealth Management. We believe that Dundee Bancorp is an overlooked net
asset play, with the sum of its individual assets worth substantially
more than the company itself. With solid operating results and good
performance from the bank and non-bank financial sectors recently, we
are anticipating greater investor interest in Dundee Bancorp.
Revenue in the first six months of 2000 was $184.7 million, up 66%
from the $111.3 million earned in the comparable period in 1999. Fully
diluted earnings per share for the period were $0.64 versus $0.59 in
1999. Mutual fund assets under management grew from $5.3 billion to $6.1
billion as of June 30. Despite the increase in assets under management,
the Company is still experiencing net redemptions, indicative of the
tough conditions that most mutual fund companies are facing. On a more
positive note, financial services revenue earned during the first half
of the year totaled $82.9 million, significantly greater than the $18.4
million earned the previous year. These improvements inspire confidence
in management's ability to integrate various acquisitions and position
Dundee for superior long-term performance.
Many Bay Street analysts do not closely follow Dundee Bancorp. As a
result, Dundee trades at a discount to its net asset value, though it
has appreciated somewhat over the past several months. Management
recognized that the Company is considerably undervalued and announced a
normal course issuer bid for a maximum of 1,614,907 shares. In lieu of
paying dividends, Dundee has taken this opportunity to purchase
approximately 10% of the public float of its subordinate voting shares.
We believe that this buyback, at anti-dilutive prices, represents a good
long-term use of funds for Dundee Bancorp and its shareholders. We
believe that investors' patience will be rewarded.
April 6, 2001
Dundee Bancorp's Dynamic Mutual Funds have returned to a net sales
position after an agonizingly long period of net redemptions. Improving
sales are directly related to deteriorating investor sentiment towards
the technology, media and telecommunication sectors. This has allowed
traditional value managers to outperform growth investors on a relative
basis.
Despite the top line growth, Dundee Bancorp remains a net asset value
(NAV) play. The Company's holdings include an investment portfolio and
an 85% interest in Dundee Wealth Management. The total value of Dundee
Bancorp's net assets fluctuate between $30 to $35 per share, depending
on the current value of its publicly held securities. Management has
recognized that the Company trades at a discount to both net asset and
book value and has taken action in an effort to improve the market value
of the shares.
On March 23, 2001, Dundee Bancorp renewed its normal course issuer
bid for up to a maximum of approximately 1.5 million shares or 10% of
the public float. The Company has already repurchased almost 500,000
shares at an average price of $14.03 per share since March 27, 2000.
Given the discount to book value, we believe that share buybacks
continue to be an excellent use of the firm's capital.
May 11, 2001
We have been long-time supporters of Dundee Bancorp. However, the
stock price has stubbornly remained below the $20 level, in large part
due to difficult capital market conditions and a lack of coverage by the
major investment houses. Even after recently returning to a position of
net sales, implying the potential for both revenue and earnings growth,
Dundee remained overlooked by the investment community.
Several developments led us to re-examine and re-evaluate our
investment in Dundee Bancorp. The Company's net asset value was
negatively impacted in the fourth quarter due to onetime write-downs at
two equity-accounted investments. Also, we had surmised that a return to
net sales would stimulate share price appreciation. Unfortunately this
has not occurred. Though we feel that the Company has good long-term
value, it is very illiquid, is barely followed by analysts and continues
to be saddled with a holding company discount. With a slim likelihood of
some other catalyst materializing in the near-to-medium term, we have
sold our entire position of Dundee Bancorp.
|
|
|
 |
|
|
| INVESTOR RELATIONS CONTACT INFORMATION |
|
|
|
 |
|
|
| LINKS TO OTHER INFORMATION |
| Quotes |
News |
Profile |
Filings |
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|