Value Library
The following is an excerpt from
the ABC Perspective - October 2007 - Pg. 16
Research, Patience and Potential
Reward
|
The secret of business is to know
something that nobody else knows.
Aristotle Onassis (1906-1975)
Greek Shipping Magnate |
As a fundamental analyst I
have always believed in the process of serious hardcore equity
research, investment patience, and significant potential rewards.
This task has often entailed a deep and tedious analysis so as to
uncover an overlooked market gem or diamond in the rough. Often
the discovery of a valuable tidbit of company information that the
market has disregarded can frequently be serendipitous. In other
cases it can be a simple question of investment curiosity and/or
good luck. Let me explain.
When we initially started to
review Fortress Paper Ltd., one of our two ABC Funds Value Favourites
highlighted on page 3 of this ABC Perspective, we weren’t terribly
excited. True, the Company appeared interesting in that it was a
Canadian-owned international producer of security papers and wallpaper
in Switzerland and Germany. However, as net asset value buyers, we
could not find a justification for purchasing this small
capitalization initial public offering. While we were about to move on
to analyze another company, we decided to take a second look at
Fortress Paper.
At that time, after poring
through the initial public offering prospectus we discovered that the
fire insurance value of the properties, inventory, the replacement
value of three 12,000 tonne production machinery, its Dresden,
Germany’s land, hydroelectric plant and water treatment facility were
significantly above the company’s market capitalization and share
price. Putting pencil to paper we reckoned that the company was
trading at a 75% discount to our estimated net asset or replacement
value. We believed that this discount was excessive for assets that
were both cash flow positive and profitable. As a result, we decided
to purchase just under 10% of Fortress Paper for our ABC Funds.
Now, while the purchase of this
lightly-traded, TSE-listed common stock was not without risk, we
believed that the serendipitous discovery of its significantly
undervalued assets made the risk/reward of this investment quite
appealing. But, more importantly, our deep-digging and discovery of
Fortress Paper’s undervalued assets, not commonly known by the
marketplace, added an exciting upside potential to an unglamourous
European production story.
As highlighted in our ABC
Perspective front page, “Testing Our Mettle”, we are often willing to
be early investors in an excellent longer term investment despite the
possibility of negative short-term performance. In summary, by
combining serious investigative research and considerable investment
patience, we believe that the longer term potential rewards of a
Fortress Paper far outweigh its shorter term market fluctuations.
Irwin A. Michael, CFA
|