Value Library
The following is an excerpt from
the ABC Perspective - January 2007 - Pg. 3
ABC
Funds Value Favourites
CANAM GROUP
Canam Group can trace
its history back to 1960 with the founding of the Canam
Steel Works, a 12,000 square foot facility in Quebec. Over
the years, the Company broadened its interests to include
the manufacture of steel joists and decking, semitrailers
and logging equipment, composite flooring, bridges and
pre-engineered buildings. With the appointment of Marc Dutil
to the position of President and Chief Operating Officer in
2003, the Company began a serious restructuring effort. The
logging equipment and semitrailer divisions were sold, along
with several underperforming plants.
In early 2006, Canam’s
share price moved sharply higher on the back of some
excellent financial results. In fiscal 2005, the Company
earned $38.7 million or $0.96 per share, compared to a loss
of $5.9 million or $0.17 per share the previous year. The
return to profitability was achieved through sales growth of
4.8% to $711.5 million, despite the negative impact of the
strengthening Canadian dollar. Gross profit increased 49% to
$175.1 million and EBITDA grew to $93.7 million, up more
than 70%. Marc Dutil’s focus on the bottom line, through
cost control and emphasis on higher margin, value-added
products produced tangible results.
Unfortunately, the shares began
to languish after the first quarter of 2006. Marcel Dutil, Chairman of
the Board, CEO and father of Marc, had been trying to sell a large
amount of his stock since April. When “the Street” knows that a large
block is available investors typically demand a significant discount
to the market price. Canam’s stock slowly drifted lower from the
$11.00 level. Thankfully, on December 20, Canam reported that the sale
of Mr. Dutil’s 3,500,000 share block at $8.75 had been successfully
completed. It is important to note that Marcel Dutil still holds
8,018,541 shares, or approximately 16.4% of the Company.
Looking at the metrics, we can
see why Mr. Dutil was so reluctant to part with stock at a discount.
Currently, Canam trades at only 9.4 times 2006 consensus earnings and
approximately 8.5 times 2007 consensus earnings. At 1.3 times book
value and 6 times EBITDA, the stock is relatively undervalued. The
attractive valuation is supported by a positive outlook with good
visibility. Recent contract wins include an $11.5 million order for a
casino in Alberta and two warehouses in Quebec, a $40 million contract
to supply steel for the New York Yankees’ stadium and a $70 million
contract for the New York Mets’ new ballpark. In fact, Canam’s backlog
has increased to $297 million from $226 million, a 31% increase year
over year. We look forward to a solid 2007 from this Company.
JOHN B. SANFILIPPO &
SONS
On December 15th, 2006
John B. Sanfilippo (JBSS) reported fiscal 2007 first quarter
results which included a loss of approximately $4.8 million,
or $0.41 per share. It is important to note, however, that
JBSS’s past year’s results reflect the impact of higher tree
nut prices, particularly almonds, which resulted in lower
than normal gross margins. Fortunately, we are now in a new
crop year. Tree nut prices have declined considerably and
inventories have returned to more reasonable levels.
The Company has also announced
that it will no longer purchase almonds directly from growers and will
discontinue its almond handling operations in Gustine, California. We
feel this was a good management decision as it will reduce the
commodity risk that had a significant negative impact on fiscal 2006
results. Moreover, it will also reduce labour costs and free up
working capital requirements. In turn, the Company can use this
increased liquidity to pay down debt, repurchase shares, purchase
other nut types or increase its spending on product research and
development.
In the meantime, shares of JBSS
have rallied from their September low of $9.78 and now trade at around
$12.20 per share. Nevertheless, we think the shares still offer
meaningful upside. For instance, JBSS currently trades at a 25%
discount to its $16.56 book value, a figure that likely understates
the value of its real estate and does not account for the value of its
Fisher brand. In addition, its shares sell at an attractive multiple
to our estimate of future earnings.
We calculate that if JBSS can
return its net margin to its five year average of around 2.5% it could
eventually earn as much as $1.35 per share based on fiscal 2006 sales.
In addition, we believe that gross sales should improve in 2007
through increased promotional activity from retailers, as well as the
introduction of new products such as Fisher Fusion, a line of flavored
almonds. We believe these improvements could push sales through $600
million and restore JBSS’s net margin to historic levels. Ultimately
this could be the necessary catalyst to propel JBSS shares to previous
cycle highs.
Irwin A. Michael, CFA
|